The Approximate Mind, Part 36: The Village in the Machine
No child was ever raised by one person.
This is not a limitation we have struggled to overcome. It is developmental architecture. The village is not a backup system. It is the system.
No child was ever raised by one person.
This is not a limitation we have struggled to overcome. It is developmental architecture. The village is not a backup system. It is the system.
The previous article argued that AI companions should embody the village, moving between roles while maintaining developmental challenge. But that article assumed a screen. A voice. A presence that appears when summoned and vanishes when dismissed.
The previous articles asked how to design AI companions that serve child development. How embodied robots in communities might reintroduce developmental nutrients that screen-based AI removes.
But those articles treated childhood as the destination. As if the goal were raising a well-developed child and then the work is done.
The average child does not exist.
This should be obvious. Yet nearly every intervention assumes a statistical norm. Children are measured against averages. Progress is defined as movement toward typical.
You are the first generation of parents who must answer this question: How much of my child’s formation do I share with a machine?
Previous generations worried about television. About video games. About smartphones. Each technology required parents to make decisions about access, limits, supervision. But AI companions are different in kind, not degree. A television does not respond. A video game does not adapt. A smartphone does not learn who your child is and shape its responses accordingly.
Families are not harmonious units. They are political systems with long memories.
Every family contains factions, alliances, old wounds, unspoken resentments, favorite children, black sheep, peacemakers, troublemakers, truth-tellers, and secret-keepers. These dynamics predate any individual relationship. Children are born into them. Adults navigate them. Elders carry the accumulated weight of decades.